What 130,000 Tractors Say About Model Year, Age and Fuel Cost

November 20, 2026

Listen to this article:

Key Takeaways

  • Fleet-wide fuel economy among study participants reached 7.48 MPG in 2025, an 18% improvement since 2010 that works out to a compounding gain of 1.1% a year.
  • Results were split by duty cycle for the first time, with linehaul fleets hitting an all-time high of 7.96 MPG and regional-haul fleets averaging 7.29 MPG.
  • The efficiency advantage over the average U.S. combination truck is worth $3,520 per tractor a year at 2026 fuel prices, up from $2,373 at 2024 prices.
  • Data from more than 130,000 tractors shows that stretching a linehaul trade cycle from three years to six adds only 1.6 cents per mile in fuel cost, or roughly $1,561 per tractor a year.

Fleets that kept buying fuel-saving equipment through a long stretch of low-cost diesel are collecting on that decision at a rate they could not have modeled when they spec’d the trucks.

Fleet-wide average fuel economy among participants in the North American Council for Freight Efficiency’s Fleet Efficiency Study reached 7.48 MPG in 2025, an 18% improvement since 2010 that NACFE calculates as a compounding gain of 1.1% a year over 15 years. In 2024, the most recent year with comparable federal data, the study fleets ran 7.4 MPG against 7.1 MPG for the average U.S. combination truck in Federal Highway Administration statistics. NACFE puts the value of that gap at $2,373 per truck per year, or $0.024 per mile, assuming 100,000 miles annually and 2024 fuel prices. At 2026 fuel prices the same gap is worth $3,520 per truck. Across the fleets that contributed data this year, the organization puts the total above $200 million.

The study, released November 19 and formerly called the Fleet Fuel Study, is the 11th update of a benchmarking exercise NACFE launched in 2012. Fifteen fleets provided data covering their 2024 and 2025 operations, including C.R. England, Frito-Lay, J.B. Hunt, KeHE, Maverick Transportation, Melton Truck Lines, Mesilla Valley Transportation, NFI, Nussbaum, Pepsi, Pilot Flying J, PITT OHIO, Ryder, Schneider and US Foods. Twenty-nine fleets have participated over the life of the study, which now covers 82 technologies and practices and roughly 40,000 data points of purchasing behavior going back to 2003.

For the first time, NACFE split both adoption and fuel economy by duty cycle. Linehaul fleets hit an all-time high of 7.96 MPG in 2025. Regional-haul fleets averaged 7.29 MPG, a figure NACFE calls commendable given the local roads, frequent stops and day cab configurations typical of the segment. The split matters because the study population itself has shifted. Regional-haul operations made up 35% of participants in 2010 and 57% in 2025, which means the overall average is being pulled down by mix even as individual fleets improve.

Adoption numbers in this edition use a balanced panel, counting only fleets that reported in both 2023 and 2025, a methodology change from prior reports. On that basis, setting engine parameters for fuel economy and in-cab cameras both reached 100% adoption, up 32% and 25% respectively. Routing optimization and vehicle data analysis for fuel efficiency each reached 92.8%, up 50% and 26%, gains NACFE links in part to the availability of AI-driven tools. Downspeeding, defined as a final drive ratio below 2.7:1, reached 84.8% and automated manual transmissions among linehaul fleets rose from 22% in 2007 to 86% in 2025. Tractor tire pressure monitoring crossed half the panel at 50.5%, up 93%, and smart air dryers and compressors rose 149% to 33.9%.

The decline list is as instructive. Nitrogen tire inflation fell to zero. Diesel auxiliary power units sit at 0.1%, down 67%. Trailer nose cones are at 0.7% and the use of hotels to avoid idling at 1.1%, each down more than 90%. Partial tractor chassis skirts fell 44% to 11.6%.

Two category-level declines carry asterisks. Tractor aerodynamics dropped sharply in both duty cycles, but NACFE attributes that to the removal of aero hoods and fenders, aerodynamic bumpers and aerodynamic mirrors from the survey on the grounds that they are now standard equipment rather than a discretionary spec decision. Trailer aerodynamics also declined, which NACFE calls an artifact of fleet mix, noting that fleets with high trailer aero adoption sat out this cycle and were replaced by fleets with lower adoption. Had the population held constant, the organization says the category would have been flat or slightly up. Thermal storage systems, snorkel-type truckstop electrification and platooning capability were also dropped. Company-paid reserved parking and renewable fuel were added.

The most actionable new material comes from a dataset Geotab supplied covering more than 130,000 U.S. linehaul and regional-haul tractors. NACFE used it to build a model-matched fuel economy index, comparing the same truck model from one year to the next to strip out duty cycle and wear effects. Linehaul trucks improved an average of 1.3% per model year and regional-haul trucks 0.7%. Over 12 years, linehaul MPG improved 17% and regional-haul 9%.

Applied to trade cycles, that produced a finding that cuts against a common assumption. At $4.15 a gallon, the five-year average EIA diesel price, a linehaul fleet running a three-year trade cycle spends 1.6 cents per mile less on fuel than one running six years. In annual terms, NACFE’s table puts a three-year cycle at $52,753 per tractor against $54,314 at six years. For regional haul the spread is narrower still, roughly $46,067 against $46,189. Fleets that have modeled large fuel economy penalties for aging equipment may find the actual number smaller than assumed, which NACFE says gives them more room in capital planning, since maintenance, uptime, resale and driver preference are likely more consequential to total cost of ownership.

“Truck age and replacement timing matter, too,” said Charlotte Argue, senior manager of sustainable mobility at Geotab, in the report.

NACFE calculates roughly a 2.8-year payback on the technologies delivering most of the savings for these fleets, and expects that to improve as higher adoption lowers purchase prices. Participating fleets range from 17% to just over 60% of available technologies in use, against a theoretical ceiling near 65% because some options compete for the same function.

The study also notes that the Environmental Protection Agency rescinded federal greenhouse gas emissions standards in February 2026, and says fleets will continue working with truck, engine and component manufacturers on efficiency regardless of the regulatory push.

“Stay technology-agnostic, stack what fits your routes, and keep adopting what works,” said Ryan Bankerd, global director of fleet and facilities at UPS, in the report.

NACFE published an interactive Technology Adoption Explorer alongside the study, with filters for technology category and duty cycle and a toggle between fleet decision weighting and unit weighting, plus a downloadable benchmarking tool for fleets outside the study.